The Big Picture

The Impact Of Rising Healthcare Costs On Insurance

A general explanation of why healthcare cost growth tends to push up premiums, shift costs to members, and change benefits, and what you can do about it.

On this page
  1. The basic link between costs and insurance
  2. Why healthcare cost trends rise
  3. How insurers set premiums
  4. Where members feel it
  5. What it means in a hypothetical year
  6. What you can do
  7. A cautious outlook

This article is general information, not insurance, legal or financial advice. Cost patterns differ by country, region and plan, and nothing here predicts what any particular plan will do. Where numbers appear, they are hypothetical.

Insurance is a way of pooling money. Members pay in through premiums, employers may add an employer contribution, and the pool pays for covered care. When the cost of care goes up, the pool has to pay out more. That money has to come from somewhere, so over time the pressure tends to show up in one or more places: higher premiums, higher cost sharing, narrower benefits or reduced choice of providers.

This does not mean every cost increase reaches members in the same year or in the same way. Insurers, employers and governments absorb some of it, delay some of it, and in some cases redesign plans to manage it.

Nobody can say with precision how much each factor contributes, and the mix differs by place. Commonly discussed reasons include:

  • Prices of services. What providers charge, and what insurers negotiate, can rise year over year. In systems with limited price competition, prices can be hard to restrain.
  • Use of care. Populations that are aging or living longer with long-term conditions tend to use more care. Better detection can also lead to more tests and treatments.
  • New technology and drugs. New treatments often improve outcomes but can add costs, especially specialty prescription drugs and advanced procedures.
  • Administrative costs. Billing, claims processing and compliance add expense throughout the system.
  • Labor costs. Health care relies heavily on skilled staff, and wages and staffing shortages affect what care costs.
  • Consolidation. When providers or insurers merge, there is ongoing debate about whether this raises or lowers prices, and findings vary by market.

General inflation also plays a part, though healthcare cost growth has at times run faster than general prices and at other times more slowly. The pattern is not constant.

How insurers set premiums

Insurers generally estimate how much they expect to pay in claims for a group of members, add costs for running the plan, and set premiums accordingly. They look at past claims, expected trends in prices and use, and the risk profile of the group. If costs are expected to rise, premiums typically follow. Government rules may limit how rates are set or require review of increases in some places, and the degree of oversight varies. Many of the reasons premium changes occur are tied directly to these cost trends, though they are not the only cause. A group’s own claims experience, changes in benefits and regulatory changes also matter.

Where members feel it

Premiums. The most visible effect. In employer plans, the employee’s share may rise or stay flat while the employer absorbs more, depending on how the company chooses to respond.

Cost sharing. Plans may raise deductibles, copays or coinsurance, or the out-of-pocket maximum, which moves a larger portion of costs to the person using care. This is one reason high-deductible plans have become more common in some markets.

Drug and service management. Plans may use tools such as prior authorization and step therapy to manage spending, add or change tiers on their drug lists, or review whether a service meets the plan’s definition of medical necessity. These tools can reduce unneeded care, though they can also create extra steps and, at times, disputes.

Network design. To control costs, some plans narrow their provider networks or steer members toward lower-cost providers. Narrow networks can lower premiums but may limit choice.

Benefit changes. Employers may adjust what they offer, such as adding wellness programs, changing spouse rules, or reconsidering which plans to provide. Small employers, in particular, may find it difficult to keep the same level of benefits.

What it means in a hypothetical year

Suppose a plan’s premium in one year is 500 per month and the insurer’s costs are expected to rise by 6 percent. If the whole increase passed straight to the premium, the new premium would be 500 x 1.06 = 530 per month, which is 360 more per year (30 x 12). In real life the pass-through is rarely this clean. Some of the increase might instead be handled by a higher deductible, and the actual change could be larger or smaller. This example only shows how a modest-sounding percentage turns into a noticeable annual amount.

What you can do

You cannot control the broader trends, but you can make choices that may soften their effect.

  • Compare your options at each enrollment period instead of letting the plan renew automatically. Premiums and benefits may have changed.
  • Look at total annual cost, meaning premiums plus likely out-of-pocket spending, not only the monthly price.
  • Use in-network care and preventive care benefits where they apply, which are often priced more favorably.
  • Ask about generic drug savings and lower-cost sites of care when options exist.
  • Review bills carefully and ask about financial assistance programs if a bill is difficult to pay.
  • If you are eligible, find out whether income-linked help is available, since it can offset part of the premium.
  • If your employer offers one, consider whether a health savings account fits your situation, remembering it comes with rules and is not right for everyone.

A cautious outlook

It is reasonable to expect that cost pressure will continue to influence plan design, but how fast and in what form is uncertain. Policy changes, new treatments, economic conditions and competition can all shift the picture. Be skeptical of confident predictions, and rely on your own plan documents and official sources when deciding what to do next.

The complete guide to the big picture

The Impact of Healthcare Reform on Your Insurance Options
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →